Centre County Judge Orders Change Handling Right-to-Know Requests About Court

HomePennsylvania Open Government ForumOpen Discussion on Open GovernmentCentre County Judge Orders Change Handling Right-to-Know Requests About Court

This topic contains 59 replies, has 2 voices, and was last updated by  Watchdog7 1 year, 1 month ago. This post has been viewed 6013 times

Viewing 15 posts - 46 through 60 (of 60 total)
  • Author
  • #7660


    The Shakespearean drama continues Updated January 10, 2017

    Quick update: A court case was enmeshed in the open records issue discussed extensively above. Jalene McClure was convicted in Centre County Court (September 2014) of an August 2010 assault on a 5-month-old child and sentenced to 10-to-20 years. Within days of sentencing, McClure’s attorney, Bernard Cantorna, filed an open records request for phone records (the open records issue described above) that showed text messages between then Centre County Judge Bradley P. Lunsford and members of the District Attorney’s Office. Some of the communications were suggested to have been made ex parte during trial. The sentence was vacated in August and sent back to Centre County Court for a new trial. Lunsford was removed from hearing criminal cases and then retired in 2015. This is where we are today.

    Clinton County Senior Judge J. Michael Williamson decided in a December out of county pretrial conference that the texts were not an influence in McClure’s trial. Williamson dismissed a motion to preclude the trial. Shakespeare wrote: “With respect to the social interaction between [Judge] Lunsford and members of the district attorney’s staff [District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller], while perhaps more extensive [than] would be anticipated in a small county, we find nothing so egregious as to warrant dismissal of the charges against the defendant.” This is, Watchdog opines, code that the extensive “ex parte communications” on county owned cell phones presumably in and out of court were “personal” not judicial in nature. The exact text of the text is protected at a level envied by the National Security Agency.

    Read more at: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/crime/article125487954.html#navlink=SecList



    Watchdogs AskNnew Pennsylvania AG to investigate Centre County DA Parks Miller

    “Two Harrisburg watchdog groups presented Josh Shapiro’s office with a request for a full investigation just after he was sworn in at noon as the state’s new AG. Gene Stilp, of Taxpayers and Ratepayers United, and Eric Epstein, of Rock the Capital, want him to take a look at the tangled relationship between Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller, convicted and resigned AG Kathleen Kane and her successor, Bruce Castor.” Read the entire article at: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/article126950414.html#navlink=SecList
    This is a good summary of the case by one of the best reporters in Centre County, Lori Falce.



    Pennsylvania Superior Court orders Judge Not to Proceed with Centre County Cases on Appeal
    Update: January 26, 2017

    Watchdog opines that Centre County and the State College area in particular have a penchant to create chaos when open records and open meetings laws are involved. This particularly includes Pennsylvania State University, the State College Area School District, State College Borough government, and now the Centre County Court System. All of this abetted by a local newspaper renowned more for stenography than investigation. Curiosity may kill a cat but never a Centre Daily Times (CDT) reporter. The CDT lacks the aggressive spirit needed to protect the Pennsylvania Sunshine Laws.

    The loonary here is embedded in long standing and deep seated “progressive” attitudes that it is best to protect institutional reputation at the cost of transparency. Violate the doctrine and kiss goodby to advertising revenue.

    Two hearings slated for January 25, 2017 at the Centre County Courthouse hit roadblocks when the state Superior Court intervened on behalf of the commonwealth. Two criminal cases (2013 and 2014 respectively) were scheduled for retrials in Centre County this coming February. The retrials are a consequence of the handling of the open records issue pertaining to alleged ex parte texting communication between a judge and the DA using county owned cell phones. The cell phone records were considered to be public not judicial records.

    The court expressed “serious concerns that the animosity, which is manifested in these proceedings between [DA] Parks Miller and [Defense Attorney] Cantorna is such that the integrity of the judicial system, as well as the defendants’ right to a fundamentally fair trial, are jeopardized if this case were to proceed to trial before the resolution of the election proceedings.” [Parks Miller and Cantorna are announced opponents in the 2017 election for county district attorney.]

    Read the details here: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/crime/article128819014.html#navlink=Lead



    Centre County DA’s Secret Fake Facebook Page Smells Like Entrapment
    January 27, 2017

    Watchdog opines this becomes worser and worser: Defense exhibit 27 (of a January 2017 filing pertaining to retrial of a 2014 Centre County criminal case) is reportedly an attempt by District Attorney Parks Miller to bar retrial of the case. It is an email form DA Miller to staff. “All, I [Miller] have made a Facebook page that is fake for us to befriend people and snoop. Her name is Britney Bella. Please edit it, post things occasionally to keep it looking legit, like things, add things, and add friends …. Use it to befriend defendants or witnesses if you want to snoop.”

    Read more: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/crime/article128875799.html#navlink=SecList

    Centre County Juror Information Questionnaire – PART 2, Question 9: Would you be less likely to believe the testimony of a police officer or other law enforcement officer because of his or her job? YES or NO



    Centre County District Attorney Parks Miller Protests Demand to Preserve Cellphone Texts
    February 1, 2017
    This Open Records case is the engine that could, its keeps going and going. Former paralegal Michelle Shutt requested a federal court to tell her former boss DA Miller to not destroy what may be evidence in a federal trial about the ongoing imbroglio. District Attorney Miller reportedly called the request galling and Shutt a liar.

    Reportedly Miller’s attorney said Miller does not possess the texts in question explaining, “Testimony has already revealed that the technology company hired by Centre County routinely factory resets every phone turned in by any county employee to protect the employee’s privacy and personal information, which happened in this case of the phone at issue in this motion.”

    In the meantime all three county commissioners, without known precedence in Pennsylvania, recused themselves from the county election board.

    Read more of the ongoing drama here: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/article129907199.html#navlink=SecList
    and http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/community/article129909289.html#navlink=SecList

    Watchdog note: URL posted elsewhere in this chronology pertaining to the conduct of Clinton County Judge J. Michael Williamson by the Williamsport Sun Gazette and The Lock Haven Express have disappeared from the Internet without explanation. Williamson presided cases involving this and other issues in Centre County.



    Federal Judge Grants Protective Order for Evidence in DA Case
    Update: February 2, 2017

    U.S. Federal Judge Matthew Brann granted an emergency motion for a protective order “prohibiting spoliation and preserving evidence.” Brann said he granted the order because it did not require anything to be turned over by the third-party, PATC Tech (a cellphone company holding the electronic devices in question). Brann explained that Plaintiff (paralegal Michelle Shutt) requests that PATC Tech maintain and not destroy potentially relevant evidence.



    Superior Court Rules in Favor of DA in Ongoing Cases
    February 11, 2017
    The article cited below provides adequate summary by the local newspaper of two cases in the center of the imbroglio involving this open records case. Watchdog opines, once again, Senior Clinton County Judge J. Michael Williamson serving in Centre County, is involved with bizarre sentencing. Unfortunately, we opine, revelation of judicial performance, is protected from Pennsylvania Sunshine Laws. Hopefully, the 2015 elections will solve much of the county’s misery.




    Voters Solved the Problem That the Courts Could Not After Two Years — Final Update, June 19, 2017

    Results of Centre County Municipal Primary Election for District Attorney

    Democrat Stacy Parks Miller: 3,135 Democrat votes, 780 write-in votes on Republican Ballot, total: 3,923 votes. Bye, bye Miller.

    There will be only one District Attorney candidate on the general election ballot in November.
    Democrat Bernie Cantorna: 7,159 Democrat votes, 3,619 write-in votes on Republican Ballot, total: 10,773 votes, 73 percent (likely a county record). Cantorna will be only candidate on both the Democrat and Republican Ballots.

    Watchdog (a registered independent) opines that because the Republican Party in Centre County is practically dysfunctional, there was no Republican candidate for District Attorney in the primary election.

    Results as of June 19, 2017 with all but 10 write-in votes resolved.



    Centre County Judge Jonathan Grine receives a “letter of counsel” from the Pennsylvania Judiciary Conduct Board
    Update: August 30, 2017

    This follows an investigation into a complaint initiated after a referral from the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania regarding conduct that took place in 2014 between Judge Jonathan D. Grine and Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller.

    According to the letter of counsel, Grine engaged in a “support relationship” with Parks Miller while having marital problems in 2014-2015, which “could lead to a charge of impartiality and could reasonably be questioned in criminal matters and that, due to the relationship, you were subject to improper influence by DA Parks Miller in your official conduct.”

    Parks Miller is also accused of several ex parte communications with former judge Bradley Lunsford who retired at the end of 2015. She is slated for a disciplinary hearing in November 2018 when she leaves office as determined by voters.

    Read more at: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/article170080472.html

    • This reply was modified 2 years, 4 months ago by  Watchdog7.
    • This reply was modified 2 years, 4 months ago by  Watchdog7.
    • This reply was modified 2 years, 4 months ago by  Watchdog7.
    • This reply was modified 2 years, 4 months ago by  Watchdog7.
    • This reply was modified 2 years, 4 months ago by  Watchdog7.


    August 31, 2017
    Protesters surround Courthouse Statue claiming ‘Corruption’ at Centre County Courthouse


    Some could opine this is nitwittery and loonary (as opposed to lunacy) and the consequence of Sunshine Laws applied to a judiciary behavior long protected behind closed doors. Watchdog suggests instead, it is the result of a branch of government whose behavior is now exposed to Sunshine abetted by modern technology and increasingly to open disclosure of discipline of the judiciary; a judiciary chosen by public election in Pennsylvania. Lesson — if Judges do not want the public to know about a behavior then do not do it under “privilege”.



    Centre County Judge Jonathan Grine ‘counseled’ by Judicial Conduct Board
    October 6, 2017
    “Following an investigation into a complaint initiated after a referral from the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania regarding conduct that took place in 2014 between Judge Jonathan D. Grine and Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller, the board voted to resolve the complaint by issuing a letter of counsel to the judge,”
    According to the August 29 2017 letter of counsel, Grine engaged in a “support relationship” with Parks Miller while having marital problems in 2014-2015, which “could lead to the charge that (his) impartiality could reasonably be questioned in criminal matters and that, due to the relationship, you were subject to improper influence by DA Parks Miller in your official conduct.”
    Read details at: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/article170080472.html

    • This reply was modified 2 years, 3 months ago by  Watchdog7.


    Pennsylvania Superior Court Order Denying McClure Double Jeopardy Retrial Vacated
    October 21, 2017
    Most who follow this open records case involving judicial impropriety and open records believed it was mostly resolved. Yet, it continues.

    Background: The prosecution of Centre County resident Jalene McClure for assault and child endangerment was the origin of the open records case. (She was convicted after a September 2014 jury trial and sentenced to 10 to 20 years. That sentence was vacated in August 2016 and a new trial was ordered in conjunction with ex parte prosecutorial shenanigans and closed records deemed protected from Sunshine laws to protect intra judicial trysts). McClure now contends double jeopardy. The Superior Court says, not so fast. Though one’s head may explode, the full details may be read at: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/crime/article180068131.html

    The drama deepens. The District Attorney in the McClure Case Stacy Parks Miller was overwhelmingly rejected for reelection in the primaries. The Defense attorney in the case Bernard Cantorna was overwhelmingly nominated by both parties for District Attorney. (None of that has anything to do with McClure’s guilt or innocence). The Centre County President Judge Thomas Kistler relinquished his position as President Judge (he remained a county judge) earlier this year. A few weeks ago Kistler was charged with DUI (0.231) after injuring a traffic director hit by his vehicle and then Kistler leaving the scene. Read more here: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/crime/article179746051.html

    Watchdog writes often about the cultural oasis created by Penn State and the State College City on the Hill Oligarchy: https://www.scribd.com/user/160046112/State-College-Watchdog
    A recent favorite is the $150 million (25 percent cost overrun) State College Area Monolith High School fraught with referendum law violations: https://www.scribd.com/document/354436696/State-College-Monolith-High-School

    • This reply was modified 2 years, 3 months ago by  Watchdog7.
    • This reply was modified 2 years, 3 months ago by  Watchdog7.


    Pennsylvania Supreme Court to Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks-Miller: DAs are part of Right-to-Know law and must comply. November 24, 2017

    It took about two years but the climax (pun intended) resulted in The Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreeing: District attorneys are not a special case when it comes to the state’s Right-to-Know law.

    The salient wording: “when Parks Miller claimed protection as a judicial agency, the Commonwealth Court said no. Seven justices of the Supreme Court agreed, in two separate opinions.

    Justice David Wecht wrote the majority opinion, going to simple definitions of the office as being “related staff” rather than actual judicial agencies, just like others — including sheriffs and public defenders — that work around the court but not as judicial staff.

    Justice Christine Donohue agreed with the decision, but was more critical about the path taken to get there.
    “I reject out-of-hand Parks Miller’s notion that district attorneys and the judiciary are on the same ‘team,’ ” she wrote. Donohue said the idea “dangerously conflates” the people prosecuting cases with those judging them impartially.
    “Parks Miller’s highly generalized view of the unified judicial system misconstrues the role of district attorneys in our constitutional system,” she wrote. Donohue also said the idea would make district attorneys more protected than the state’s attorney general, who is recognized as a member of the executive branch rather than the judiciary, calling the idea “absurd and unreasonable.”

    Go here to read the complete article: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/article186316443.html#navlink=SecList



    Centre County’s former DA, Stacy Parks Miller, Cited by Pennsylvania Supreme Court Disciplinary Board for Total Disregard for Her Office. June 5, 2018

    “The conduct of Centre County’s former district attorney warrants no less than a three-month license suspension because she fails to comprehend the seriousness of ex parte communications and minimizes her misdeeds, according to the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.”

    “Stacy Parks Miller made a conscious decision to run the risk of engaging in deceptive conduct, without sufficiently considering the implications of the conduct,” Disciplinary councilman Anthony Czuchnicki said in his brief.

    Czuchnicki said Parks Miller violated 14 rules of professional conduct, including knowingly or recklessly making false statements during the board’s investigation and on multiple occasions, and misrepresented material facts in order to avoid further investigation,” Read the entire article at: http://www.centredaily.com/news/local/article212476339.html

    Watchdog opines — ONLY THREE MONTHS? How about three years, 6 months confinement, $60,000 and permanent loss of law license? Miller was a District Attorney not a first year lawyer.

    • This reply was modified 1 year, 7 months ago by  Watchdog7.
    • This reply was modified 1 year, 7 months ago by  Watchdog7.



    State College ( Pennsylvania) self-flatters as the City on the Hill where political harmony reigns, all children are gifted, taxes are rational, and liberals immune to the foibles of illiterate luminosity. And hence most of the senior Centre County Court fell into their own trap.

    In September 2018 the Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania on recommended Former District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller’s law license be suspended one year. If the suspension is final, she would need to secure approval from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court for reinstatement and to operate her newly opened law firm sans clients. The request for Supreme Court Action explained: “Miller betrayed the faith and trust of the public by engaging in misconduct in her official capacity, including dishonest acts, and this factor weighs heavily in the assessment of discipline.” (Previously a hearing committee recommended she be suspended for three months for engaging in ex parte communications with Centre County judges.) And no, her contention of self-imposed time served does not count. Two judges “retired.” Miller and the judges were not immune to to RTK statues.

    Read more at: https://www.centredaily.com/news/local/article222781465.html

    All of this sordid tale was discovered through access to public records, first refused for disclosure because they were “judicial records”, but then obtained on appeal under authority of the Pennsylvania Freedom of Information Act.
    Subsequently, Centre County President Judge Thomas Kistler (judge at the time of the Miller incident and who also retired) was later sentenced to 12 months in an accelerated rehabilitative disposition (ARD) program because of a 2017 DUI. In the same incident he barely evaded being charged with leaving the scene of the accident after reportedly hitting a traffic control officer at Pennsylvania State University. Not understanding the gravity of DUI, Kistler filed (August 2018) a motion to the court asking for an early termination of his ARD program because he could not apply for senior judge status with pending criminal charges. Unfortunately for Kistler but not for an outraged public, a probation officer reported that Kistler violated ARD by consuming beer at the Red Horse Tavern on Sept. 13th. Kistler’s motion was denied.

    In The City on the Hill, laws are intended for the Hoi pollo but not the oligarchy. Thank God for the Pennsylvania Freedom of Information Act and the Coalition.

    Read More: https://www.centredaily.com/news/local/crime/article219023460.html

Viewing 15 posts - 46 through 60 (of 60 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.